Rare Half-Male, Half-Female Cardinal Spotted In Pennsylvanian Garden


Katy Evans

Katy is Managing Editor at IFLScience where she oversees editorial content from News articles to Features, and even occasionally writes some.

Managing Editor

gynandromorphic cardinal

The beautiful half-male, half-female (gynandromorphic) cardinal . Photograph by Shirley Caldwell

Bird-spotters, twitchers, nature lovers, people spend years spying on wildlife in the hope of seeing, perhaps even capturing on camera, a rare and wondrous sight. A couple from Pennsylvania did just that, when they noticed a very unusual bird hanging out in their garden.

One side of the bird, a northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis), had the spectacular scarlet plumage so iconic of the male, and the other half, the soft brown-green of the female, split down the middle.


“Never did we ever think we would see something like this in all the years we've been [bird] feeding,” Shirley Caldwell told National Geographic, after she and her husband Jeffrey spied the bird in their garden in Erie, Pennsylvania.

The bird popped up a few weeks ago, and she snapped the picture of it while it was chilling in a dawn redwood tree just 9 meters (30 feet) from their kitchen window.

Gynandromorphy is more obvious in species that are sexually dimorphic, where the male and female adults' appearances are different, like northern cardinals. Bonnie Taylor Barrie/Shutterstock 

So, is it really half-male, half-female? Yes. Although rare, bilateral gynandromorphism – where a species' external appearance is split down the middle, half male, half female – has been seen in a variety of organisms, including birds, insects, and crustaceans.

In fact, it possibly occurs more often than thought, and we only notice it when it's really obvious, like in a species that is sexually dimorphic, where there are differences in the appearance of adult males and females.


Sex determination in birds is basically the opposite of humans. Instead of the females having two copies of the same sex chromosome (XX) and the male having a copy of each (XY), in birds it’s the other way around. Birds’ chromosomes are Z and W, so the female has ZW and the male has ZZ. So males’ sperm only carries Z, while females produce eggs with either Z or W.

Gynandromorphy occurs differently in different species. In birds, it’s thought that it happens when an egg develops with two nuclei, one carrying a Z, the other a W. If it gets fertilized by two ZZ sperm, then the embryo will carry both ZW and ZZ cells.

Photograph by Shirley Caldwell

Can gynandromorphic birds themselves breed? "So far as we know, yes," Dr Alex Bond, senior curator in charge of birds at the Natural History Museum, told IFLScience. Although it may not be plain sailing. "If the gynandromorphy is complete, then birds will have one ovary and one testis. But all birds have just one urogenital opening – the cloaca. So externally they would look the same." 

However, "If the breeding involves sex-specific behaviors, like songs or courtship dances, though, these may be only partial or modified, meaning the bird won’t be as attractive to the partner it’s trying to woo."


Back in 2014, researchers studied another bilateral gynandromorphic northern cardinal for over a month and observed that it never paired up, or sang. It's possible its behavior, rather than its looks, confused other cardinals. 

"Much like some hybrids exhibit behaviors from both species, gynandromorphs combine aspects of behavior from both sexes," Dr Bond explained. "In some cases, they may sing like a male, but have the courtship dance of a female. Or the song and/or behavior may only be partial."

So it may not be easy for this particular cardinal to find love, but Shirley remains positive, revealing it has been spotted a few times in the company of a male. 

“We’re happy it’s not lonely,” she said. "Who knows, maybe we will be lucky enough to see a family in summer!" 


[H/T: National Geographic]