spaceSpace and Physics

Watch Cyclohexane Boil And Freeze At The Same Time


Stephen Luntz

Stephen has a science degree with a major in physics, an arts degree with majors in English Literature and History and Philosophy of Science and a Graduate Diploma in Science Communication.

Freelance Writer

558 Watch Cyclohexane Boil And Freeze At The Same Time
Tom Enstone. What happens when a substance freezes and boils at the same time.

We think of freezing and boiling as opposites, things that happen at very different temperatures. However, under conditions of low air pressure the two can occur together, as we see in this video.

Substances can only be liquid in the presence of a gas to apply vapor pressure. If there is no pressure, or too little pressure, a substance will go straight from solid to gaseous phase as it warms. If you do this in an enclosed space the gas produced will build up, creating pressure as it does so, until a liquid phase is possible. If not enclosed, the gas will escape and the process can continue indefinitely.
The most familiar example is solid carbon dioxide, also known as dry ice. Liquid carbon dioxide needs much higher pressure than most other common substances. Under atmospheric pressure it will be a gas above -78.5C (-104.2F) and solid below that temperature. Take some solid carbon dioxide into a room and watch it go straight to gas (but careful, the extreme cold will “burn” you if you touch it).
The video above is what happens if a liquid is placed in conditions where the temperature is right at the point where it freezes and the gas pressure is removed. With no pressure it can't stay liquid, but it is right on the cusp between boiling and freezing, so it does a little of both.  Going from liquid to gas absorbs energy, while liquid to solid changes release it. This can keep the process in balance - if too much material boils the temperature will fall, shifting the balance in favor of freezing.
Some coverage has wrongly described the video as showing the triple point. However, at the triple point gas, liquid and solid can all survive indefinitely. What we are seeing is what would happen anywhere along the dotted lines on the graph below to the left of the triple point.
We don't see this sort of thing often because if we performed such an experiment in a closed environment the boiling gas would build up pressure, allowing the remaining material to stay liquid. In the video that is addressed by constantly drawing off the vapor.
HT Io9


spaceSpace and Physics