spaceSpace and Physics

Ice Can Behave Very, Very Oddly In Space


Stephen Luntz

Stephen has a science degree with a major in physics, an arts degree with majors in English Literature and History and Philosophy of Science and a Graduate Diploma in Science Communication.

Freelance Writer

bubbling ice

Ice with a similar composition to comets at hundreds of degrees below freezing will bubble when exposed to UV light. Arrows show newly appeared bubbles as time elapsed during exposure to UV. Tachibana et al.

Space doesn't do liquids. In a vacuum, a substance can be a solid or a gas, but liquid states don't exist. This means when a comet warms up, its ice sublimes rather than melts, turning directly to gas. Exceptions exist, however. When exposed to ultraviolet light, the mixture of ices found on comets and in planet-forming disks can bubble and flow like a liquid, even at very low temperatures. The discovery could help explain how giant planets form, and even how the conditions for life on Earth arose.

The ice we see on comets or the moons of the outer planets is not made from pure frozen water. Instead, it represents a mixture, principally of water, methanol, and ammonia, but also including more complex molecules that form the building blocks of life. Dr Shogo Tachibana of Hokkaido University replicated the simpler components in the lab and exposed layers just a few micrometers thick to ultraviolet light.


At temperatures of 65º-150º Kelvin (-208º to -123º C / -343º to -190º F), the ice bubbled like a liquid. The same occurred when Tachibana tried the experiment with pure water ice, but at somewhat lower temperatures. On the other hand, Tachibana and co-authors report in Science Advances that ice with the same composition, but not exposed to UV radiation, did not respond the same way.

The bubbles were a few hundredths of a millimeter (less than a millionth of an inch) across. When temperatures were raised a little further, the ice sublimed, leaving behind organic materials and traces of bubbles. The bubbling was a result of the ice molecules being broken apart by the radiation, and molecular hydrogen released in the process escaping. Higher concentrations of water reduced the amount of bubbling, which suggests that most of the hydrogen was coming from the ammonia and methanol. Similarly, the liquid-like behavior has been attributed to the rearrangement of hydrogen bonds induced by the UV radiation.

Crucially, the amount of UV light required to induce liquefaction is similar to that in parts of protoplanetary disks exposed to a sun-like star. In other words, something similar was probably occurring on the surface of planetesimals in the early days of the Solar System as they began aggregating into planets. The authors calculate the same thing may occur on the outskirts of planet-forming disks in star clusters as a result of radiation from sibling stars.

Although any hydrogen that bubbles off would reduce planitessimals' mass, liquefaction could make it easier for small objects to stick together, explaining how planets at the right distances from stars form so quickly. If the necessary components for life did indeed arrive on Earth from comets, understanding how these molecules respond in space could be particularly important.


spaceSpace and Physics
  • tag
  • ice,

  • hydrogen,

  • UV radiation,

  • Comets,

  • sublimation,

  • liquification,

  • bubbling,

  • organic compounds