spaceSpace and Physics

Astronomers Spot Black Hole So big, It Defies Current Theories Of Galaxy Evolution


Jonathan O'Callaghan

Senior Staff Writer

1053 Astronomers Spot Black Hole So big, It Defies Current Theories Of Galaxy Evolution
An illustrated view of a black hole that outgrew its galaxy via Michael S. Helfenbein/Yale University

Almost all galaxies are thought to have a supermassive black hole at their cores that make up at most 0.5% of the galaxy’s total mass.

So the discovery of a galaxy called CID-947 with a black hole that makes up 10% of its mass has left scientists dumbfounded, possibly overturning current theories of how galaxies evolve.


This 11.7-billion-year-old supermassive black hole appears to have grown much faster than its host galaxy. Forming two billion years after the Big Bang, it is among the most massive black holes ever found, with a mass of about seven billion times that of the Sun.

Lead author on the study, Benny Trakhtenbrot from ETH Zurich’s Institute for Astronomy, said in a statement that it was a "gigantic black hole within a normal-size galaxy," far exceeding the size expected for black holes in galaxies. Speaking to IFLS, he added that "the black hole had to grow first, and the galaxy is experiencing its period of maximum growth later."

That the galaxy was still forming stars and continuing to grow was surprising, as it challenges theories that radiation emitted by expanding black holes would stunt the creation of new stars.

It may be that the galaxy is a precursor to more massive and extreme galaxies seen in the universe, but its growth would still upend existing theories about galaxy evolution. According to, the discovery may support the theory that black holes grew incredibly rapidly in the early universe, as the cosmos was smaller and denser.


The discovery, published in the journal Science, was made using the Hawaii-based Keck Observatory’s new MOSFIRE instrument. It came as somewhat of a surprise though, as the team was performing a "routine" hunt for black holes and had not expected to find anything so exotic.

"This project specifically targeted moderate black holes that inhabit typical galaxies today," said Claudia Megan Urry, Yale's Israel Munson professor of astrophysics and co-author of the study, in a statement. "It was quite a shock to see such a ginormous black hole in such a deep field."

The international team behind this project includes astronomers from Yale University, ETH Zurich, the Max-Planck Institute in Germany, Harvard University, the University of Hawaii, INAF-Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma and Oxford University.


spaceSpace and Physics
  • tag
  • black hole,

  • galaxy,

  • telescope,

  • study,

  • evolve,

  • supermassive