Ancestry Tests Come Back Saying Identical Twins Have Different DNA

billions photos/shutterstock

Rosie McCall 23 Jan 2019, 18:52

Ancestry tests are becoming increasingly popular with more and more people eager to discover their heritage. But the science can be somewhat dubious.

Even Paul Maier, the chief geneticist at FamilyTreeDNA, suggests we should all take the results with a generous pinch of salt by admitting it is "kind of a science and an art". And the experience of Charlsie Agro, host of the Canadian show Marketplace, and her identical twin goes to show exactly that.

Charlsie and her sister, Carly, bought home DNA kits from five different brands: AncestryDNA, MyHeritage, 23andMe, FamilyTreeDNA, and Living DNA. Next, they took samples of their DNA to send back to the companies for testing.

The Agro sisters are identical twins, so you would expect them to have (almost) identical DNA and, therefore, (almost) identical results. But, as you've probably guessed by now, that's not what happened. 

The Living DNA results found that Charlsie has DNA from Scotland and Ireland while Carly has a small percentage of ancestry from England.

The 23andMe results suggested Carly is almost 10 percent more "broadly European" than Charlsie. Meanwhile, Charlsie has 2.6 percent French and German ancestry, which Carly, apparently, does not. Charlsie also came back as 3.3 percent more Eastern European, 1 percent more Italian, and 1 percent more Balkan than her sister. Hey, at least, they can agree that the twins are largely of European descent.

Perhaps more puzzling is the differences between brands. AncestryDNA gave the twins mostly Eastern European heritage (38 to 39 percent), MyHeritage mostly Balkan (60.6 percent to 60.7 percent), while FamilyTreeDNA found that between 13 to 14 percent of their DNA came from the Middle East.

Of course, if these tests were 100 percent accurate, they would come back with identical results. So to find out what is going on here, Marketplace had the results from the five companies sent to Yale University for analysis.

Full Article

If you liked this story, you'll love these

This website uses cookies

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By continuing to use our website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.