Rediscovered Essay Reveals Churchill's Thoughts On Alien Life

Shortly before the outbreak of war and becoming prime minister, Churchill wrote a recently recovered article on the prospects for life on other worlds. Public Domain via Wikimedia commons

In 1939, Winston Churchill wrote an 11-page article on the prospect of life beyond Earth. Shortly afterward, events kept him otherwise occupied and the paper was not published. After the war, Churchill updated the paper, but for unknown reasons it didn't get run then either. The lost document was rediscovered last year and has now been analyzed in Nature, revealing that even as Churchill tried to warn the world of the dangers of fascism, he had time to think deeply about this topic. His conclusions largely match those of astrobiologists today.

Astrophysicist Dr Mario Livio, the first scientist to get to examine the paper, wrote: “At a time when a number of today’s politicians shun science, I find it moving to recall a leader who engaged with it so profoundly.” Today, with thousands of planets known around other stars, discussion of life elsewhere in the universe is widespread, but Churchill was writing long before any exoplanets had been discovered and well before the Drake Equation attempted to quantify the chances of life elsewhere. Although he included discussion of the habitability of planets in our Solar System, he also looked further afield.

The dominant theory of planetary formation in the 1930s proposed that a passing star had pulled material from the Sun. Such an unusual event would have made planetary systems like our own very rare. Churchill acknowledged this, but expressed skepticism about the model, pointing out that double stars are common and writing: “If they could be formed, why not planetary systems?”

In line with modern thinking, Churchill argued that the presence of liquid water was the prime requirement for life on other worlds. Although he acknowledged other liquids might provide substitutes, he stressed that “nothing in our present knowledge entitles us to make such an assumption.” From this, he drew the idea of what we now call the “Goldilocks Zone”, which is that life cannot exist either too close or too far from a star, and that planets must fall within a narrow size range. Even Churchill's definition of life, and discussion of whether viruses should count, is evidence of how well he understood the topic, Livio argues.

Churchill was also fully aware of the challenges of interstellar travel, expressing hopes that voyages to Mars and Venus might happen soon, but concluding we might never know if planets around other worlds house life.

The fact that Churchill was writing about a scientific topic that was obscure at the time might surprise those who know him only for his leadership in World War II, or perhaps his much less glorious influence on Middle Eastern history. However, Churchill had a life-long interest in science and wrote popular science articles explaining evolution, microbiology, and possible future technologies through the 1920s and 30s.

Churchill's interest in, and understanding of, science played a decisive part in winning the war. He was Britain's first prime minister to hire a science adviser. Alan Turing's code-breaking efforts never faced the hostility represented in the recent film of his life, but military high command were resistant to giving him the scarce resources he needed for success. It was Churchill, with his familiarity with the cutting-edge of science, who understood the potential of Turing's work and instructed that he be given what he needed to crack the German codes, one of the most important decisions in the war.

Comments

If you liked this story, you'll love these

This website uses cookies

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By continuing to use our website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.