Alcohol Can Protect Eyewitness Memory

Memory preserving serum? Jorge Royan/Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-NC-SA

Danielle Andrew 09 Mar 2017, 11:50

Ever witnessed a punch up during a boozy night out? Did you assume that you probably wouldn’t be a reliable witness because you’d been drinking? You may have been right, but our latest research indicates that in some circumstances this is not the case. The Conversation

There is a strong link between alcohol and crime. According to the Crime Survey for England and Wales, 70% of public violent incidents in 2013-14 were alcohol related and 93% of those happened in pubs, bars and clubs where alcohol is sold. Given these numbers, it is likely that many witnesses and victims will be under the influence when they witness a crime. But are drunk witnesses always less reliable than sober ones?

In certain situations alcohol can have a beneficial effect on memory. Our study, published in Psychopharmacology, shows that if alcohol is consumed after witnessing a crime it can protect memory from misleading information.

The 83 participants in our study watched a video of a staged theft, where a man and a woman entered a house and stole some jewellery, money and a laptop. The robbers then swiftly left the property, before the homeowner could stop them.

After watching the film, participants were split into three groups. Members of the first group were given alcohol and were aware that they had been given it. The second group were told they would be drinking non-alcoholic beer, but in fact did drink alcohol (the purpose of this was to ensure as far as possible that it was the effect of the alcohol itself and not expectations about the effect of alcohol that would cause any effects). And the third group did not get any alcohol and knew they were not drinking.

On average, participants did not exceed the English drink-drive limit of 80mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood. All participants were then exposed to some fake information about the crime video. For example, it was suggested that the victim’s jumper was green instead of blue and the thief’s hair was brown instead of black. The following day, all participants returned to the lab when sober and their memory about the crime was tested.

Drunks are better than their reputation

While previous research suggests that alcohol may harm memory and make people more suggestible, our study found that those who did not drink alcohol were more likely to remember false information compared with those who had, whether they knew they were consuming alcohol or not.

We think this is because alcohol blocks new incoming information, including misinformation, so it is less likely to have a negative impact on what was witnessed.

Full Article

If you liked this story, you'll love these

This website uses cookies

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By continuing to use our website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.